November 1, 2026 · 6 min read
Are Home Prices Falling? Two Reports Landed the Same Day and Disagreed
Redfin says U.S. home-sale prices fell 0.1% year over year. NAR says they rose 1.7%. Both are right, and here is what it means in New England.

Two national home price reports landed on October 29 and told opposite stories. Redfin said the median U.S. home-sale price slipped 0.1% from a year earlier in the four weeks ending October 25, its first annual decline in more than three years. The same day, the National Association of REALTORS said the median price of an existing single-family home rose 1.7% in the third quarter to $432,900, with prices higher than a year ago in 78% of the metro areas it tracks. Neither report is wrong. They are measuring different things, and knowing the difference is what separates reacting to a headline from reading a market.
What each report actually measures
Redfin's figure is a four-week rolling median, seasonally adjusted, covering sales that closed through October 25 and counting condos and townhouses alongside single-family houses. It moves quickly, it gets revised, and it is sensitive to which homes happen to close in any given four weeks. The same report put the median asking price at $400,703, still up 1.2% year over year, which tells you sellers have not changed their minds. Buyers have changed what they are willing to pay.
NAR's figure is a quarterly median of closed single-family sales, so it covers July, August and September and stops before the stretch Redfin is describing. It is slower and smoother, and it carries the detail the headline hides: 78% of metros posted gains, 21% posted declines, and only 4% posted double-digit gains, down from 5% in the second quarter. A national median is a summary of hundreds of very different local markets, not a description of any one of them.
New England sits in the stronger column
On the question that matters locally, the two reports point the same way. NAR put the Northeast median at $561,500 in the third quarter, up 4.0% and the highest of the four regions. Hartford-West Hartford-East Hartford ranked among the top 10 price gainers in the country at 7.5%, and Bridgeport-Stamford-Norwalk came in at $874,200, up 3.5%. In Redfin's late-October data, no Northeast metro appears among the biggest annual price declines, while Seattle at 5.1% lower, San Jose at 4.9% lower and Austin at 4.6% lower all do. Boston showed up instead on the list of metros with the biggest increases in new listings, up 12.8%.
What both reports agree on
Demand is the weak link. Redfin counted 276,352 pending sales in its four-week window, down 15.9% from a year earlier and the lowest level in its records, with pending sales falling in all 50 of the most populous metros for a third straight week. Active listings were up 2.2% at about 1.51 million, supply reached 4.5 months, which Redfin treats as the low end of balanced, and 21.5% of listings carried a price drop, up from 20.9% a year ago. New listings fell 4% to their lowest level since January, so sellers are stepping back too. Median days on market sat at 50.
The reason is on the rate sheet, not in the price column. Freddie Mac's survey put the 30-year fixed at 7.24% for the week ending October 29, down from 7.32% the week before and the lowest reading of the month, but far above the 6.17% of a year earlier. The 15-year fixed was 6.60% against 5.41% a year ago. Redfin's estimated median monthly payment was $2,786, up 10.7% year over year and the second highest on record. Prices barely moved. The cost of carrying them did. As an illustrative calculation, a $450,000 purchase with 20% down leaves a $360,000 loan, which runs about $2,453 a month in principal and interest at 7.24% against about $2,198 at 6.17%, a difference of roughly $256 a month or about $3,066 a year. That figure is arithmetic, not a quoted statistic, and it leaves out taxes, insurance and any association fee, all of which matter in Rhode Island, Massachusetts and Connecticut.
If you are buying
A flat national median is not a discount, but the conditions behind it are real leverage. Roughly one listing in five has already cut its price, the typical home is sitting for 50 days, and there are more sellers than buyers in most markets for the first time in over a decade. That is the moment to ask for what used to be unaskable: a seller-paid rate buydown, closing cost credits, repairs identified at inspection, a longer rate lock. Run the full payment including escrows before you fall for a list price, and buy to the number you are comfortable with rather than the ceiling your pre-approval allows.
If you are selling
The gap between the $400,703 median asking price and the $389,601 median sale price is the entire story of this market in two numbers. Sellers are still pricing to last spring and the market is clearing somewhere below that. In Rhode Island, Massachusetts and Connecticut you still have the regional tailwind NAR described, but a tailwind is not a bid. Price to the comparable sales that actually closed in the last 60 days, not to the highest active listing in the neighborhood, and treat the first two weeks of showings as your real appraisal. A correctly priced listing in a 4.5-month market still sells. An aspirational one collects price drops.
Frequently asked questions
Are home prices falling in 2026?
It depends on the measure. Redfin's four-week median U.S. sale price was 0.1% lower year over year in the four weeks ending October 25, 2026, its first annual decline in more than three years. NAR's third-quarter median for existing single-family homes was 1.7% higher at $432,900, with gains in 78% of metros and declines in 21%. Nationally, prices are flat to slightly lower on the fastest measures and still modestly higher on the quarterly ones.
Are prices falling in Rhode Island, Massachusetts or Connecticut?
Not in the latest regional data. NAR put the Northeast median at $561,500 in the third quarter of 2026, up 4.0% year over year and the strongest of the four regions, with Hartford up 7.5% and Bridgeport-Stamford-Norwalk up 3.5% at $874,200. No Northeast metro appeared among the largest annual price declines in Redfin's late-October figures.
Why do Redfin and NAR report different home prices?
Different measures. Redfin publishes a seasonally adjusted four-week rolling median that includes condos and townhouses and is revised as data arrives. NAR publishes a quarterly median of closed single-family sales, which covers an earlier and longer period and smooths out short-term swings. Both can be accurate at the same time.
Is now a good time to buy if prices might fall further?
Nobody can tell you where prices go next, and a 0.1% national move is not what decides whether a purchase works. What decides it is the payment you will actually carry, including taxes and insurance, and how long you plan to own. At 7.24% the financing cost is doing far more to your budget than price movement of a percent or two in either direction, which is why shopping lenders and negotiating seller credits matters more right now than timing a national index.
Sources
- Redfin, Housing Market Update, October 29, 2026, four weeks ending October 25, 2026
- National Association of REALTORS, Metropolitan Median Area Prices and Affordability, third quarter 2026, released October 29, 2026
- Freddie Mac Primary Mortgage Market Survey, week ending October 29, 2026
